How Much of Your Retirement Savings Should Be Invested in Large Caps?


With the demise of traditional pension plans, many individuals are finding themselves needing to be more involved in their retirement planning.  Whether many people feel like it or not, a 401K plan is actually superior to a traditional pension plan because one can get much better returns, all of the money is available when one is ready to retire, your retirement future doesn’t rely on the future fortunes of the company for which you work, it enables people to change jobs without worrying about loss of retirement benefits, and it allows companies and public entities to better manage their finances and avoid making promises that will be difficult to keep in the future.

One question that many accidental investors have is how to allocate the money in their 401K and other retirement plans.  For example, what percentage should be in large caps, small caps, and other areas of the market.  Let’s look at the area of large caps, meaning large America-based companies.  How much of your retirement savings should be in large caps?  Well, that depends.

Large caps are safer than small caps and mid caps for several reasons:

1.  They are large companies with several business lines, allowing them to easily survive slowing markets in one or two sectors.  Apple can sustain a drop in computer sales because they are also selling iPods and iPads.  They can sustain a drop in mall traffic because they are also selling online.  Heck, they are even selling clothing and probably marketing their logo.

2.  They tend to be international, meaning that they are not as affected by a slowdown in the US as a purely domestic company would.  You should also buy some international mutual funds, but you do get international exposure by buying Coca-Cola and Intel.

3.  They tend to generate a lot of cash from their operations, meaning they have the money to take advantage of opportunities.  If they want to enter a market, they do so.  If they need to do research and development, they can.

4.  They are able to pay dividends, which provides the investor with an income during stagnant markets and reduces losses during down markets.

5.  They are able to pay their CEOs a lot, meaning that they can attract some of the best talent.  An entrepreneur might find a corporate board room too stuff and restrictive (not to mention boring), but there are a lot of Magna Cum Laude ivy league business school graduates who have proven themselves very good at running a company clamoring for the CEO jobs at large companies.

With that safety, however, comes a sacrifice in your possible returns.  For one reason, because they are safer they tend to be valued  higher relative to prospective future earnings.  People pay more for the shares because they know they are likely to get a reliable return.  This means you return over long periods of time will be less in large caps than it will be in small caps.

There is also just the aspect of size.  An investor looking for capital gains is less likely to get a 100% gain, let alone a 1000% gain or a “ten-bagger” by selecting a large cap than he is by selecting a small cap.  Because the share price tends to track earnings, earnings need to double for the share price to double.  It is a lot easier for a company that is make $1 Million in sales each year to double its earnings than one making $1 Billion.

For these reasons, the percentage of large caps in your portfolio should be based on your need for growth and your tolerance for risk.  Someone who is twenty years old might choose to put nothing into large caps for the first few years since he won’t need the money for fifty years and has little to lose.  He really needs growth.  Someone who is fifty-five, however, should favor large caps over small caps since the day when he’ll need to start using his 401k for life expenses is rapidly approaching.  In general, it is good to have some exposure to all areas of the markets, but the amount of exposure should vary based on your stage in life.

Those goosed-up returns from a portfolio consisting only of small caps will also come with a lot of turbulence.  You might make a 20% annualized return over a period instead of a 12% return, but there may be some years with 30% or 40% drops in value along the way.  Spreading the money out definitely helps reduce volatility and generally doesn’t hurt your returns very much, especially when looking at the reduction in risk.

So I would probably start out in a career right out of school heavily weighted towards small caps and mid caps, but be moving some money into large caps as the portfolio value built up.  I might therefore do something like this with the stock portion of my 401k:

Age 20-25: 10-20% US large caps,

Age 25-35:  25% US large caps,

Age 35-50:  40% US large caps,

Age 50-60:  60% large caps,

Age 60-65: 65% large caps,

Note also that the percentage invested in stocks, versus being invested in real estate, bonds, and other income assets would shrink as I got older.  I would keep my age minus 10% in income assets, so at age 60 I would only be 50% in stocks.  This would mean that while my stock portfolio would be 65% large caps, only about 32% of my entire portfolio would be.

These are just rough guidelines.  The point is that one needs to shift into safer investments, like large caps, as one gets nearer to retirement.  Looking at the larger picture, the most important thing is to invest regularly and leave the money alone so that it will be there when you are ready to retire.  Anyone who is putting money away regularly and who resists the urge to cash out their 401k on some lark will be far better off than those who wait until their late forties or fifties to get serious about retirement.

Disclaimer: This blog is not meant to give financial planning advice, it gives information on a specific investment strategy and picking stocks. It is not a solicitation to buy or sell stocks or any security. Financial planning advice should be sought from a certified financial planner, which the author is not. All investments involve risk and the reader as urged to consider risks carefully and seek the advice of experts if needed before investing.

Comments appreciated! What are your thoughts? Questions?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.