Instead of myRA Accounts, How About Privatizing Social Security?

I thought President Obama was slurring his words during the State of the Union speech when he spoke about “myRA” accounts.  It turns out it is a new program he is proposing, saying that it does not require new legislation to create (not sure how that works).  Some details on the program are given in this Reuters article.

It certainly is a great thing to get people saving for retirement.  Almost everyone will need to have money for retirement and almost everyone makes enough during their lives to provide for a comfortable retirement if they would save and invest.  Still, with a limit of $15,000 and yields of 2% or less, I’m not sure that this new myRA is the best way to go.  With that low a limit, and that low a rate of growth, someone might only be able to pay for a year of retirement expenses before the funds were depleted, and that is assuming no large medical bills

A better alternative would be to allow workers to direct their Social Security payments to a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA instead of the money going into the abyss of the general fund as is currently done.  All workers currently contribute about 13% of pay per year, which is about $3900 per year, or $325 per month, for someone making $30,000 per year.  Over a 45 year career, even assuming no raises, that would create a $1.7 M account (in current dollars) at retirement if 8% were earned per year after inflation.  That could provide about $68,000 in income per year (in current dollars) for life if invested in an annuity at retirement or 4% were simply taken out each year.

A common argument against this is that this would be risking money in the stock market, while traditional Social Security and the proposed myRA accounts would be in safe, guaranteed investments.  The ability for both of these programs to provide the specified benefits, however, relies on the government’s ability to continue paying benefits.  This capability will come very much in question over the coming years as the national debt soars and the number of retirees drawing Social Security and Medicare grows.  Even if the national debt doesn’t become unwieldly and the US Government’s ability to borrow at very low interest rates continues, the income of the Federal Government is directly related to the prosperity of the economy.  If enough US businesses fail to cause a risk to IRA plans, there won’t be any revenues going to the Federal Government either.  The converse is not true, in that a default of the US Government will not necessarily result in a crash of US company stocks.

So how would individuals who are not familiar with investing be able to manage a portfolio of stocks?  The answer is that they would not need to do so.  Deposits could be invested automatically in a total stock portfolio when a worker is 20-30 years old.  At age 30, 10% of the funds would be shifted into a total bond fund.  This would continue, with 10% of funds shifted into bonds with each passing decade of a worker’s life.  At age 70 a worker would have an appropriate portfolio of about 40% stocks and 60% bonds.  Simple.

Note that in some ways this would be what Social Security was supposed to be – young workers paying in while older workers pull money out.  As older workers are selling stocks and using the money for their expenses, younger workers will be buying stocks and supporting the prices of the funds.  The only difference is that the value of the funds will increase automatically with inflation, since the value of the companies will increase with inflation, and the growth in the value of the companies owned by the funds will result in a wealth compounding effect.  The existing system does not have this wealth compounding effect since all funds are spent as they are received.

So, instead of creating myRAs, how about we look at improving the existing government retirement program – Social Security.  It already collects plenty of money to provide a comfortable retirement for even workers just above the poverty level.  The secret is to allow workers to invest the money they already contribute.

Contact me at, or leave a comment.

Disclaimer: This blog is not meant to give financial planning advice, it gives information on a specific investment strategy and picking stocks. It is not a solicitation to buy or sell stocks or any security. Financial planning advice should be sought from a certified financial planner, which the author is not. All investments involve risk and the reader as urged to consider risks carefully and seek the advice of experts if needed before investing.



  1. They also threw the stat out there that 28% of workers had less than $1,000 in retirement savings. Clearly the problem is that people CHOOSE not to save. So why make a new IRA that the average worker will ignore?

    The government needs to be smart enough to realize that the programs that worked 30 years ago are no longer viable today and into the future and make some real changes to them.

    MyRA will be another useless govt program that hardly anyone will use. You can already buy govt bonds with an IRA account as well as other very safe options. Anyone savvy enough to have a roth set up will most likely already be aware of this.

    Privatizing SS would be too easy of a fix for the meager returns it offers for workers, but disabled people wouldnt accumulate enough for it to benefit them so our current system is basically only better for disabled people. Which is why disability fraud is so common, because you are tapping into money you never contributed and in return never have to work again.

    • Thanks for reading and commenting. I’ve heard some talk that the real reason for the myRA is that the government has run out of rich people to borrow from so they are now looking to borrow from poor people. I’m not that cynical, however.

Comments appreciated! What are your thoughts? Questions?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.